This is a discussion on Synopsis of T44 Testing from 1951 through 1953 within the The M14 forums, part of the M14 M1A Forum category; Originally Posted by Random Guy Its too bad about the innovative T25 rifle, which I think had a much more ergonomic design of the stock ...
| ||LinkBack||Moderator Tools||Display Modes|
|May 13th, 2020, 09:07 AM||#16|
Join Date: Apr 2015
Location: North Carolina
The T25 wasn't all that good a rifle. In 1949-50, it was the front runner for the lightweight rifle program. In 1950, the T25 was tested along with the British EM-2 and the FN FAL (the later two in .280 British).
The T25 had better semi-automatic accuracy, did well enough in the rain, sea water immersion, and grenade tests, but was the worst performer in mud, dust and dry tests. It ejected almost straight up, so spent brass had a tendency to rain on your head during full auto fire, or if firing from the hip, fly straight into your face, it was difficult to field strip, the magazine was described as "leaves much to be desired", and broke a lot of parts.
The report ranked it third of the three, however it did qualify that in stating is was the only one of the three the shoot a full power cartridge.
After that test the T25 went back to the drawing board and was largely redesigned from muzzle to butt plate and re-designated the T47. Mainly simplifying it by removing the "open-bolt full auto" feature, and attempting to correct some of the faults, with varying degrees of success.
I didn't mention it, but at the last two tests done by the Army Field Forces, the temperate and arctic tests of 1953 - 54, the T47 was present and tested alongside the T44 and the FN. It did not fair very well again. Its performance was sufficiently below both the T44 and FN they didn't even bother suggesting changes.
Oh, and just in case you think I am just parroting biased reports, I'll allow you to decide for yourselves on where the the T25/T47 was really worth pursuing as a replacement for the M1 Garand: Here are the tools listed in the "Operator's Manual" for field stripping the T47:
- Drift, Brass, Large
- Drift, Brass, Small
- Hammer, Small, Brass
- Tool, Trigger Guard Release
- Wrench, Allen Head
- Wrench, Gas Cylinder Plug
Last edited by lysander; May 13th, 2020 at 11:03 AM.